Rassie Erasmus questions consistency on citings and TMO interventions ahead of Ireland clash

Rassie Erasmus questions consistency on citings and TMO interventions ahead of Ireland clash

Springbok head coach Rassie Erasmus has voiced strong frustration over perceived inconsistencies in disciplinary processes and in-game officiating, particularly around dangerous tackle techniques.

Speaking to reporters on Monday, Erasmus addressed the citing of Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast for a hip-drop tackle on Fiji captain Peceli Yato during Ireland's win over the weekend.

Prendergast was not sanctioned during that game but faces a disciplinary process under World Rugby's newly emphasised rules targeting the technique.

"I must say the right words now. We are in the Northern Hemisphere, I think there's going to be a technicality, and he is going to play," Erasmus told reporters.

"It's Monday, and the story is in the papers. Was it within the 12-hour period when they cited him? When Jasper got cited, it was six hours after the game without being in the papers.

"In the Northern Hemisphere, players probably get cited two or three games before being available for selection again.

"In my experience⦠I'm not 100 percent how it works, I'm not a legal guy and I don't have the right to say anything on it. But from my experience here with the cases of Lood de Jager, Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Franco Mostert, it just never seems to go our way.

"I'm not saying anyone is doing anything wrong; I'm just not expecting Prendergast to get cited and that he'll play on Saturday.

"Tadhg Furlong was accused of the same offence as Jan-Hendrik. Again, I don't want to go into the details because I'm not a legal person, But from a South African point of view, it hurts where we felt it was more or less the same situation, and Jan-Hendrik got banned nine weeks, and Furlong for three."

On the Prendergast incident itself, the coach was unequivocal in his assessment.

"I think the hip drop from Prendergast tackle was terrible. In my opinion, compared to when we were in the World Rugby meetings, and all coaches were there apart from the Irish and French coaches, and we had a three-hour discussion regarding the hip-drop tackle," Erasmus said.

"It's difficult to understand when a TMO sits there, and he sees something we discussed at the World Rugby meeting, and the examples of what it is were shown over and over, and we all had our input.

"And somebody sees that happens and decides there's nothing wrong with it.

"All of our coaches were there and gave our input. So when you see it, and you decide there's nothing wrong with it, how do the other coaches feel?

"How did Jake [White] feel when one of his players got injured and was carried off the field? We all felt it was an immediate red card. Everyone watched the game live, and that's exactly what they said a hip-drop tackle is.

"I swear I'm not moaning; I'm just trying to give you a perspective of somebody who comes and plays against, for example, in France or Ireland."

He framed the cultural and procedural differences as part of the challenge for Southern Hemisphere teams.

"It's foreign to us; we have Afrikaans and Xhosa-speaking people in our group, and we're not well schooled on how things get said regarding legal ways and the right way one must do things," he explained.

"I remember when I got my ban with the referee thing when I referred to the lady as ma'am, and she said 'I'm not a ma'am', and I apologised, but we don't always understand these legal things."

Erasmus also claimed France made several tackling infingements against the Springboks that went unpunished.

"We deserved to lose to France, and it's our own fault, but the other thing that was brought up in the World Rugby meeting was the knee-drop tackle," he said.

"I give you my word, there were 17 knee-drop tackles by France against us. Again, I'm not claiming the referee didn't see it, or he judged it well.

"I just don't understand the narrative where people want a TMO to stay out.

"For me, and I'm going to say it as it is. You want a TMO to stay out, and two things happen: Firstly, safety and player welfare is something that's being promoted in the game and is a priority.

"The second thing is the right team must win. So if you see something that should be penalised or yellow carded and you ignore it, the conclusion must be that you're influencing the result of the team.

"Or you're letting somebody get hurt if you see it. If you didn't see it, sure it's a mistake someone made.

"I don't understand why we had those meetings and then in our game, out of those 17 tackles, 11 of those were at least a penalty and three of them I felt were at least a yellow card.

"Not one was sanctioned or showed out with players being cited. I'd send you the playlist, but I'll get into trouble.

"I can't send the playlist to anybody, and we can only send five clips to World Rugby.

"We'll query it, but the answer will probably be that it was a mistake and they should've penalised it. The same might go for Prendergast's citing. So who am I to judge that? My guy feeling is that he'll play on Saturday."

READ MORE: Springboks determined to make amends against Ireland