Inside the breakdown that forced Stellenbosch-Pirates semifinal out of the Cape

Inside the breakdown that forced Stellenbosch-Pirates semifinal out of the Cape

Stellenbosch residents’ opposition to hosting either Soweto giant at Danie Craven Stadium, alongside failed negotiations between the PSL and DHL Stadium, has been central to the venue complications surrounding the Carling Knockout semifinal against Orlando Pirates, SABC Sport can reveal.

The concerns around Danie Craven stem from the pitch invasion involving Kaizer Chiefs supporters in August 2022, when Amakhosi faced Stellenbosch in an MTN8 quarterfinal encounter.

There was chaos outside the stadium before kick-off, with hundreds of ticketless supporters causing congestion, forcing entry and breaching security gates. Matters deteriorated further after Chiefs won on penalties, as celebrating supporters stormed the pitch, triggering a security breach and forcing players, technical staff and broadcasters to seek cover.

The PSL subsequently fined Chiefs R200 000, with half suspended on condition that the club did not commit a similar offence.

Stellenbosch have not hosted Chiefs at Danie Craven since. 

Their Nedbank Cup quarterfinal against Amakhosi in March 2025 was moved to Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium.

A similar situation unfolded ahead of the Pirates fixture, with the PSL taking the concerns around Danie Craven into account. 

SABC Sport understands Stellenbosch informed the league that Athlone Stadium was unavailable, while negotiations with DHL Stadium failed to produce an agreement in time for the fixture.

The stadium is believed to have tabled several conditions, including no access to the DHL Stormers’ changing rooms or presidential suite, limited hospitality availability for the PSL, clubs and sponsors, and reduced-price tickets for its own guests.

The ticket proposal presented another complication, with the PSL needing to consult both clubs given the existing revenue-sharing arrangement, under which 40 percent goes to each club and 10 percent to the league.

The biggest sticking point was understood to be indemnity costs. 

DHL Stadium wanted the PSL to cover insurance-related costs for venue workers, including cleaners and security personnel, rather than activating its own insurance arrangements.

Stellenbosch also proposed Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium as an alternative, but Moses Mabhida Stadium in Durban was ultimately selected when the PSL announced fixtures dates, times and venues for the semifinals this weekend. 

“It is certainly a regrettable situation, particularly given the significance of the occasion, but it is one that is unfortunately outside of Stellenbosch FC’s control,” CEO Rob Benadie said in a statement on Monday night. 

“We sincerely apologise to our supporters who were looking forward to cheering on the team at home. We share in their disappointment and will do everything to make them proud in Durban as we look to reach a fourth Cup final in as many years.”

It is also public knowledge that Western Cape teams have struggled for several seasons now to host high category fixtures at the DHL Stadium due to unavailability associated to mostly costs.